A sudden federal raid outside the Row Hotel migrant shelter in Midtown Manhattan on Monday morning sent waves of panic through both migrants and nearby residents. The operation, reportedly conducted by a joint task force involving federal immigration officers and local law enforcement, unfolded just after dawn near 8th Avenue, temporarily shutting down parts of the bustling area.
Witnesses described the scene as chaotic, with unmarked vehicles and heavily armed officers blocking the surrounding streets. Migrants staying at the shelter, which has served as one of New York City’s main housing sites for asylum seekers, said they were caught completely off guard as agents began detaining several individuals outside the hotel entrance.
Confusion and Fear Among Shelter Residents
The Row Hotel, once a tourist landmark near Times Square, has in the past year become a central point in the city’s migrant housing efforts. Housing thousands of asylum seekers from countries including Venezuela, Ecuador, and Haiti, it has often faced public scrutiny, management challenges, and political controversy.
Also Read
Monday’s raid, however, introduced a new layer of fear for those living there. According to several residents, no advance notice was given about the federal presence. Some migrants reportedly avoided leaving the shelter for much of the day, fearing further arrests or deportation actions.
“I saw people running inside, crying. Nobody knew what was happening,” said Carlos Méndez, a Venezuelan asylum seeker who has been staying at the shelter since August. “They told us this was supposed to be a safe place.”
City Officials Express Concern
City officials and advocacy groups were quick to respond to the incident. A spokesperson for the New York City Department of Social Services confirmed that the city had not been informed in advance about the federal operation. “Our priority remains the safety and well-being of all individuals under city care,” the spokesperson said.
Mayor Eric Adams expressed frustration at the lack of communication between city and federal authorities. Speaking at a press briefing later in the day, he called for “better coordination” in dealing with migrant-related enforcement actions, emphasizing that surprise operations only deepen mistrust.
“We cannot have agencies acting independently in ways that undermine public trust and destabilize communities,” Adams said.
Federal Response and Justification
Federal officials described the raid as part of a targeted enforcement effort focused on specific individuals with outstanding deportation orders. A Department of Homeland Security (DHS) statement clarified that the operation was “carefully planned and executed in accordance with federal law,” adding that “no action was taken against individuals without pending legal matters.”
However, civil rights advocates questioned the timing and location of the raid, calling it “reckless” to carry out such actions near a migrant shelter.
“The optics of conducting a raid outside a humanitarian facility send a chilling message,” said Lena Torres, a representative from the New York Immigration Coalition. “Even if the targets were specific, the broader impact is fear and trauma that ripple through an already vulnerable population.”
Migrant Crisis in New York
The Row Hotel has been symbolic of New York City’s struggle to manage one of the largest influxes of asylum seekers in decades. Since 2022, over 200,000 migrants have arrived in the city seeking shelter and assistance. City officials have repeatedly stated that local resources are stretched beyond capacity.
Recent policy changes introduced by the Adams administration, such as imposing 30-day limits on shelter stays for migrant adults, have already heightened uncertainty among residents. The federal raid, some advocates say, may drive more migrants into hiding or deter them from seeking official help.
“People need to know they can access shelter and legal support without fear of being targeted,” said attorney Sarah Duvall of Legal Aid NYC. “When raids happen at or near these sites, it sends the opposite message.”
Community Reaction and Protests
Within hours of the incident, activists and community leaders gathered outside the Row Hotel to demonstrate against the federal action. Carrying signs reading “Stop the Raids” and “Protect Asylum Seekers,” protesters demanded greater transparency from federal authorities.
Local residents were divided. While some expressed sympathy for the migrants inside, others voiced frustration at the ongoing strain the migrant crisis has placed on Midtown neighborhoods. “We feel compassion, but the city looks out of control right now,” said long-time resident Deborah Klein. “Raids like this just add more tension.”
Police maintained a visible presence around the hotel for much of the day, but by evening, the immediate area had calmed.
Broader Political Implications
The raid arrives amid escalating debate over federal and state responsibilities in handling the migrant influx. President Donald Trump’s administration has emphasized stricter enforcement nationwide, while city and state officials, mostly Democrats, continue to push for more funding and local discretion in managing arrivals.
Legal experts note that these tensions could deepen as federal priorities diverge from city policies designed to protect asylum seekers. “This event highlights the fractured nature of intergovernmental coordination,” said political analyst Raymond Ortiz. “It reflects the broader clash between federal immigration enforcement and urban humanitarian policy.”
What Happens Next
As federal authorities review the operation’s outcomes, New York City officials have called for a meeting with DHS to demand clarity on future enforcement actions involving city shelters. Meanwhile, migrant aid groups have pledged to increase legal support for shelter residents who fear deportation.
Late Tuesday, city workers were seen entering the hotel to ensure welfare checks for families and minors still residing there. Though no further raids were reported, unease remained heavy in the air.
FAQ
Who carried out the raid?
The operation was reportedly conducted by federal immigration agents supported by local law enforcement officers.
Were any migrants detained?
Officials have not released exact numbers, but multiple witnesses reported at least a few individuals were taken into custody.
Did the city approve the raid?
No. New York City officials confirmed they were not notified beforehand.
What is the Row Hotel’s role in the migrant crisis?
Originally a hotel near Times Square, it was converted into a temporary shelter to house asylum seekers as part of the city’s emergency response.
Is further enforcement expected?
Federal sources have not confirmed additional operations, but city officials have demanded prior notice for any future actions involving shelters.
